Hiring contractors

Contractor or employee in Canada: how the CRA decides

Updated · 6 min read · CA

Short answer: For CPP and EI, the CRA asks whether a worker is in business on their own account. It first looks at what the parties intended, then tests that against the facts: control, ownership of tools and equipment, chance of profit and risk of loss, and the ability to subcontract or hire helpers. Provincial employment-standards law can reach a different answer.

The two-step approach

Following the Supreme Court's decision in 671122 Ontario Ltd. v. Sagaz Industries, the central question is whether the person is performing services as a person in business on their own account. The CRA first establishes the intent of the parties (often from the written agreement) and then checks whether the working relationship actually reflects that intent.

  • Control over the work, schedule and methods.
  • Who provides tools and equipment, and who pays for them.
  • Ability to subcontract work or hire assistants.
  • Degree of financial risk, investment and management.
  • Opportunity for profit and risk of loss.

Rulings and consequences

Either party can request a CPP/EI ruling from the CRA. If a worker is found to be an employee, the payer may owe CPP contributions, EI premiums and income tax that should have been withheld, plus penalties and interest.

Contractors who make more than $30,000 in taxable supplies in four consecutive quarters generally must register for GST/HST — another sign of being in business.

Provincial rules and Quebec

Employment standards (minimum wage, vacation pay, termination notice) are mostly provincial, and each province applies its own test. Ontario's Employment Standards Act, for example, has its own approach and specific rules for digital platform workers.

In Quebec, civil-law concepts apply (contract of employment vs contract of enterprise or for services under the Civil Code), and the Charter of the French Language affects the language of contracts. Our Canadian contractor agreement includes a Quebec language clause when you choose Quebec.

Frequently asked questions

Is an incorporated contractor always a contractor?

Not automatically. Incorporation is a strong indicator, but if the individual would otherwise be an employee, the corporation may be treated as a personal services business with unfavourable tax treatment.

Do Canadian contractor agreements need an annual interest rate?

If you charge interest on late payment, the federal Interest Act (s.4) requires the rate to be expressed as an annual rate, or interest is capped at 5% a year. Our templates state the annual equivalent automatically.

Sources

Not legal advice. cheapdocs provides self-help templates and software, not a law firm or lawyer. Laws change and differ by location — have a qualified professional review important documents. Read the full disclaimer.